In 2026, the most mature consulting firms will win - not the largest

For boutique consulting founders, the last two years have probably felt… flat.

While pipelines remained stagnant, budgets continued to tighten, and firms that grew effortlessly from 2018-2022 suddenly found themselves fighting for every opportunity.

But here's the good news: according to research shared by SPI Research (and we've seen it ourselves with clients & prospects), even in a flatter market, the most operationally mature firms can pull ahead - increasing profit, cashflow, staff & client staisfaction.

Maturity doesn't care about size. It cares about how well your firm runs: your sales discipline, project controls, pricing strategy, resourcing capability, and financial visibility.

When those improve, so does everything else - utilization, margin, EBITDA, growth potential and, ultimately, the valuation of your business.

‍

Why leaders should care about maturity right now

Research into consulting performance shows that the biggest performance leaps come when firms upgrade how they operate - especially during periods where revenue isn’t growing.

Mature firms outperform because they:

1. ‍ Run tighter operations - forecasting demand & availability to optimize utilization
2. Shift from T&M to fixed-fee or value-based engagements - while protecting margin‍
3. Use technology to improve visibility and profitability - e.g. AI-enabled PSA ‍
4. Monitor cash, billing and revenue recognition with real-time & forward-looking financials

None of these rely on increases in pipeline or new sales strategies. Getting fixated on operations = a healthy business.

In short: mature firms thrive even when the market doesn’t.

‍

Benchmarking: the fastest path to maturity

CMap’s research repeatedly show that high-performing firms obsess over measurement, visibility, and comparing themselves to objective metrics, not gut feel. Benchmarking helps leaders understand:

• Whether their utilization targets reflect reality
• If their margins are competitive
• How their pricing strategy compares to peers
• Whether their operational model is holding them back
• What “good” and “great” look like at different stages of growth

For boutique consultancies aiming to grow from “lifestyle” to “investable,” benchmarking is often the turning point, because it shines a bright light on where the next maturity leap is.

‍

Find your gaps & opportunities- take part in the benchmarking survey

If you want to understand where your firm sits on the maturity curve, and how to move to the next stage, complete the benchmarking assessment and listen to the full podcast conversation with SPI.

Complete the benchmarking survey

https://spiresearch.com/reports/2026-ps-maturity-benchmark/

Listen to the podcast

• Listen on Spotify
• Listen on Apple
• Listen on CMap